Document Type : Original Research Article
1 Graduate, Department of Midwifery, School of Nursing and Midwifery, Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, Mashhad
2 a. Assistant Professor, Nursing and Midwifery Care Research Center, Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, Mashhad, Iran b. Department of Midwifery, School of Nursing and Midwifery, Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, Mashhad, Iran
3 a. Professor in Biostatistics, Social Determinants of Health Research Center, Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, Mashhad, Iran b. Department of Epidemiology and Biostatistics, School of Health, Mashhad University Medical of Medical Sciences, Mashhad, Iran
4 Associate Professor, Department of Chinese Medicine, School of Iranian Traditional medicine, Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, Mashhad, Irans
Counseling is one of the most appropriate health interventions to raise the knowledge and attitude of clients (1). As a contributing factor, counseling facilitates the relationship between counselors and clients. This practice leads to better conceptualization of the clients’ characteristics and improvement of the decision-making process in life in a more reasonable and appropriate manner (2). Planning reproductive health programs, especially the ones designed for promoting childbearing, requires the actual participation of people. This participation of the community in such programs is relevant to the level of awareness and knowledge about the need for such program (3).
The Action Plan for the Population and Development Conference in Cairo (1994) stated that all human should achieve the highest level of information (4). The provision of information and education is the main strategy for changing the dominant fertility discourse of society, which has had a clear effect on the fertility behavior of couples in recent years (5). Provision of reproductive health cares, especially family planning services and counseling on healthy fertility, is one of the important skills that midwives ought to acquire for the delivery of pertinent services.
Reproductive health means that people have freedom to choose, reproduce, and decide on the time and frequency of their childbearing (6). There are many individual factors, such as attitude, motivation (7-8), as well as social and environmental factors (e.g., economic status and cultural and population policies) which can influence the fertility preferences and behaviors in the society (9-13).
For many years, healthcare staff has played a significant role in fertility-related programs. They have been mostly providing education and counseling for clients toward the aim of family planning programs (5). In recent years, along with changes in population policies in Iran, many actions have been taken to increase the rate of fertility in the society. Therefore, the role of healthcare providers is to promote attitudes and provide family planning counseling and services in line with the new population policies of the country. The achievement of this goal requires training and changing the attitudes of health providers to enable them to inform
and persuade families about the healthy childbearing (5, 11).
However, there was not enough education for providers with the aim of improving their attitude toward childbearing and promote their skills in this regard. The Office of Population, Families, and School Health planned some Interventional programs in order to increase the overall fertility rate and promote childbearing. In this regard, the emphasis was placed on staff training about reproductive health rights, improving the quality of counseling services, reviewing the fertility health program indicators, and upgrading the present educational contents (14). Improvement of performance, knowledge, and attitude of the women employed at health centers and medical sciences universities will result in the modification of clients’ performance as they act as role models and reliable sources of information for the public (11, 15).
Awareness of reproductive health can be developed using various sources, including newspapers and mass media. However, healthcare workers play a leading role in raising public knowledge in this regard (3,11). In Iran, the midwifery and health staff can make a significant contribution to enhance educational programs. The enhancement of consciousness level and positive attitude towards the program in this group results in a higher impact on the society (16). Accordingly, our previous study showed that the performance of health providers was poor in counseling with the childbearing promotion approach due to their poor knowledge and attitude toward childbearing (17).
With this background in mind, the current study was conducted to determine the knowledge and attitude of midwives and health care providers about childbearing in Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, Mashhad, Iran, in 2015.
Materials and Methods
This cross-sectional study was conducted on 108 multi-profession midwives and family health providers with at least 6 years of work experience in midwifery, maternal, and child health and family planning units in health and treatment centers and community health centers. For this purpose, three out of five districts health centers in Mashhad, including districts No. 2, 3, and 5 were randomly selected. In the next step, 18 health and treatment centers and 23 community health centers covered by these three district centers were randomly chosen as clusters and all their eligible working midwives and health providers were entered the study.
All subjects were able to work with the computer and Internet. They had BSc or MSc degrees of midwifery, family health, or public health. The data collection tools included demographic characteristics form, and two questionnaires for assessing the knowledge and attitude.
The knowledge assessment questionnaire was a researcher-made tool, including eight items. The subjects selected their responses out of two options of ‘Yes’ or ‘No’. The correct answer was given two scores, whereas the wrong ones were assigned a score of one. Based on the obtained scores and a maximum score of 16, the knowledge scores of ≤ 8, 8.1-12, and ≥ 12.1 were regarded as indicating weak, moderate, and good levels, respectively. The validity of this questionnaire was assessed and confirmed by seven teachers of reproductive health, midwifery, and nursing disciplines.
The participants’ attitude was assessed by filling out the Attitude to Childbearing Questionnaire. The items of this questionnaire were generated based on the results of a qualitative study performed by Khadivzadeh et al. (2013) on the process of forming fertility decisions among the Iranian couples (18). This instrument includes 47 items rated on a five-point Likert scale (i.e., strongly agree=1, agree=2, no idea=3, disagree=4, strongly disagree=5). Based on the scores obtained from the questionnaire, attitude scores of <118, 118-178, and >178 were indicative of weak, moderate, and good levels, respectively. The maximum score of this research instrument was 235.
The validity of the questionnaire, was approved by twelve faculty members from the midwifery, reproductive health, nursing, and psychology disciplins. After applying their comments, the content validity ratio and content validity index were calculated, and the tool’s content validity was confirmed (19).
The reliability of the attitude questionnaire was estimated using the Cronbach's alpha coefficient of 0.89. Before filling the questionnaires, the purpose of the research and the confidentiality of the information were explained to the heads of the health centers and health care staff. The subjects were entered the study based on inclusion criteria.
The data was analyzed using SPSS software (version 16) and presented as mean, standard deviation and frequency. The comparison of the quantitative and qualitative data between the two groups was done using the independent t-test and Chi-Square test, respectively. Pearson and Spearman correlation coefficient tests were also applied to show the relationship between quantitative data. p-value less than 0.05 was considered statistically significant.
The results of the study showed that 52 (48.6%) participants were in the age range of 31-40 years. Furthermore, 69 (64.5%) cases were married, and most of them (43%) had 1-2 children. In terms of employment status,
61 (57%) participants were employed as contractors and 42 (39.3%) cases were working as multi-profession. In addition, 75 (70.1%) subjects stated that they were not familiar with the new policies on fertility control and had not completed a specific course in this regard.
According to the results, 70 (65.4%) health workers had a good level of knowledge (Table 1) and regarding the attitudes toward childbearing, 75 health workers (70.1%) had a moderate attitude (Table 1). The mean scores of health workers' knowledge and attitude about childbearing were obtained as 12.86±1.36 and 166.45±19.99, respectively. The subjects’ knowledge showed a significant correlation with their age, duration of study, duration of marriage, and work experience (Table 2).
Table 3 presents the frequency of responses to the items of attitude questionnaires.
The results of Pearson correlation test showed no significant relationship between knowledge about the childbearing and attitude toward it (p=0.62). In this regard, people with higher knowledge did not necessarily have a more positive attitude toward childbearing.
The results of the correlation test showed a significant direct relationship between the attitude scores of health care staff and the work experience (P=0.03). Accordingly, health workers who had less work experience had a more positive attitude toward childbearing. Moreover, there was a significant relationship between and the source of information (P=0.03). In this respect, the health staff stated that television would be the most important source of receiving knowledge on childbearing consistent with new policies.
On the other hand, the level of knowledge had no significant relationship with the field of academic education, occupational experience, level of higher education, marital status, spousal job, spousal education, paternal education, maternal education, place of residence, level of income, and type of employment. Furthermore, the level of attitude demonstrated no significant relationship with occupational experience, field of academic studies, level of higher education, spousal job, spousal education, maternal education, paternal education, place of residence, level of income, and type of employment.
The current research was targeted toward the investigation of the knowledge and attitude of health workers about the childbearing. The results of this study showed that the participants had a good level of knowledge about this issue. On the other hand, the attitude toward childbearing was at a moderate level in most of the subjects.
The maximum and mean scores of knowledge in this study were 16 and 12.86±1.36, respectively. This indicates that the knowledge of healthcare staff was at a good level. This finding is probably due to sufficient information and presence of necessary information resources in the field of childbearing as it is an important topic among the other health issues. In the present study, television was the main source of information reflecting the role of the national media. This finding may be due to the lack of sufficient scientific resources especially books in this regard.
Salem et al. performed a study in Rafsanjan city, Iran, (2007) to assess the knowledge, attitude, and practice of healthcare staff about family planning. They showed that 82.2% of the employees had a good level of knowledge about family planning, which is consistent with the country policies at the time of study (3). The reason for these results can be explained by the health education and advices that have been taught to the staff in the past decades through in-service education and media, especially television, with a focus on contraceptive and family planning methods.
The results of the study conducted by Rahimikian et al. (2007) with the aim of assessing the effect of a training program about the emergency contraceptive methods on knowledge and attitude of health staff working in health care centers showed that most of the subjects (45.5%) had a poor level of knowledge about contraceptive methods before the intervention (20).
There are some other studies that showed no ideal levels of knowledge on health issues among health staff. Abdollahi (2005) demonstrated that 64.8% and 20.1% of the participants had moderate and good levels of knowledge about folic acid administration, respectively. Furthermore, they reported that a higher level of knowledge was attained through counseling during pregnancy (21). The researcher stated that success in health interventions depends on the knowledge of health professionals about its importance and their willingness to transmit this information to mothers.
In another study performed by Khani et al. (2008), the results indicated that health workers' knowledge about breast cancer prevention programs were at a moderate level (22). It seems that in the study of Khani, health workers were less aware of the benefits of screening for breast cancer when it is asymptomatic. This unawareness may be due to the lack of sufficient scientific resources about such important issues.
In this study, the mean score of attitude toward childbearing was 166.45±19.96 (out of 235) signifying that most of the health workers had moderate attitudes in this regard. The study of Salem et al. showed a good level of employee’s attitude toward family planning. It should be noted that the aim of family planning programs in the past decades was to promote contraceptive methods, which is totally in contrast with the aims of new action plans focusing on healthy fertility promotion (3). Enhancement of knowledge can change and improve the attitude (23). The results of a study carried out by Rahimikian et al. (2007) showed that the attitude of a high percentage of subjects (47.4%) toward contraceptive methods was not at an ideal level before training (20). In the mentioned study, the attitude was correlated with the subjects’ knowledge.
In our study, there was no relationship between the levels of knowledge and attitude. Additionally, the level of knowledge showed
no significant relationship with academic discipline, occupational experience, level of education, marital status, spousal job, spousal education, paternal education, maternal education, place of residence, level of income, and employment status. Likewise, attitude toward childbearing demonstrated no significant relationship with the mentioned variables.
In a study performed by Direkvand et al. (2011), knowledge was significantly associated with age, occupation, and education of men and their wives (24). In a study carried out by Rahimi-Kiyan et al. (2007), the field of study and the education level were related to the level of knowledge (20). Similarly, in the study of Salem et al., knowledge showed a significant relationship with age and education (3). In general, it can be stated that the variance of knowledge cannot completely change the attitude. In other words, awareness alone is not enough, but there are many other contributing factors that may have a role in attitude formation.
Some of the limitations of the present study include high workload of health staff and the overcrowding of the workplace that may influence their responsiveness as the control of these factors was not completely possible.
The findings of this research indicated that the knowledge and attitude of healthcare staff about the childbearing were at good and moderate levels, respectively. Based on the findings of this research, there was no relationship between the knowledge and attitude of health care staffs in this regard. Therefore, considering the importance of fertility in society and the factors affecting attitude, as well as the role of attitudes in the performance of health staff in the field of fertility enhancement, it is essential to design some especial educational programs to improve the attitudes and practice of health workers and community health providers toward healthy childbearing.
This article is part of a research thesis approved by Mashhad University of Medical Sciences with the code No. 931438 and Research Deputy of Mashhad University of Medical Sciences. Hereby, Mashhad University of Medical Sciences and all health officials and staff involved in this study are appreciated.
Conflicts of interest
The authors declare no conflicts of interest.